ZRG Insights
< View all
<
The Smartest People In The Room®

Five key factors to audit success

Five key factors to audit success

For CFOs and finance leaders entering the audit process

3
min.
read

No one likes surprises. For those who have been through an audit, this sentiment resonates deeply, from auditors to CFOs, whether it's their first audit or their tenth. Audits demand preparation, focus, and collaboration. With the right strategies, they can also reveal opportunities to strengthen operations and improve efficiency.

For U.S.-listed companies, a clean opinion on the financial statements is only part of what's at stake. CFOs must certify periodic reports, support management's conclusions on internal control over financial reporting (ICFR) with evidence and make sure material information reaches decisionmakers and SEC filings on time. Management remains responsible for the financial statements and effective ICFR, while the audit committee appoints and oversees the independent auditor. That makes audit readiness an always-on discipline rather than a year-end request list. Here are five keys to help prepare for your next audit.

1. Whether private or public, the first audit is tough

For fast-growing private companies, the first audit is often the hardest. Public companies aren't immune to challenges either. Even with streamlined processes, unexpected complexities can arise. An audit may be necessary because of regulatory requirements or requests from investors, acquirers, or other stakeholders, but the audit experience depends heavily on how prepared the company is to meet the auditor's demands.

Events like implementing a new accounting system, adopting recent pronouncements, or facing significant staff changes in finance can create gaps in readiness. Even highly efficient public companies may encounter roadblocks with complex accounting issues.

Falling behind has visible consequences. Business reporting cited 140 non-SPAC public companies that reissued corrected financial statements during the first ten months of 2024, up from 122 in the same period a year earlier. The same reporting linked inadequate internal controls to an increase in delayed annual reports. An adverse ICFR opinion can coexist even when the auditor concludes the financial statements are fairly presented.

Preparation is essential, whether you're a large corporation or a nimble startup. For public companies, that starts with one CFO-led readiness plan that maps the audit scope, filing timetable, significant accounts, locations, systems, specialists, new transactions, and control changes. Form 10-K deadlines are currently 60 calendar days for large, accelerated filers, 75 calendar days for accelerated filers, and 90 calendar days for all other registrants.

2. Strengthening books and records adds lasting value

One benefit of the audit process is the chance to improve recordkeeping and reporting. Audits expose weaknesses that could hinder business insights, particularly when decisions rest on flawed financial information. Addressing these gaps proactively makes financial statements more useful to the management team well before the audit begins.

A repeatable, controlled close is the foundation. Complete reconciliations, consolidations, journal-entry review, intercompany eliminations, cut-off testing, and disclosure tie-outs early enough for meaningful review by management and auditors. PCAOB standards identify significant management delays, unavailable personnel, and unexpected difficulty obtaining evidence as matters auditors must communicate to the audit committee.

The same discipline applies to significant accounting judgments and estimates. For material estimates, document the method, source data, significant assumptions, alternatives considered, sensitivity, and consistency with operational plans, along with evidence that contradicts the conclusion as well as evidence that supports it. Under PCAOB AS 2501, auditors evaluate methods, data, assumptions, and potential bias, as well as the accuracy and completeness of company-produced information. A PCAOB inspection report covering 2025 audits at one major firm found significant deficiencies concentrated in revenue, long-lived assets, accounting methods, and estimates. The inspection was risk-weighted and doesn't represent all public-company audits, but it signals where scrutiny is likely to be intense. Front-load revenue, impairment, valuation, debt classification, and other judgment-heavy work.

New standards are adding pressure. FASB's income tax disclosure amendments, effective for public business entities for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2024, require more detailed rate-reconciliation and income-taxes-paid information. FASB's expense-disaggregation standard takes effect for annual periods beginning after December 15, 2026, with interim requirements following for periods beginning after December 15, 2027. Dry runs before mandatory adoption, with new disclosures traced to controlled source systems, keep these changes from becoming audit-season surprises.

Fixing these issues before the audit lets management make well-informed decisions with accurate data and get the most out of its financial reports.

3. Take stock of your team's expertise and fill any gaps before the audit

Audit readiness requires a team with both technical and operational accounting skills. Identifying gaps in expertise and addressing them through training, skill rotation, or third-party support can significantly ease the audit process. This is not a one-time-only exercise; the importance of continuously assessing talent cannot be overstated.

Talent with deep audit expertise is increasingly hard to find, so working with external partners to achieve "audit readiness" can save time and costs. "A lease issue or account reconciliation issue can steal time from CFOs, from accounting teams, from sales teams, from development teams," said Shappell. This kind of disruption can be avoided when issues are identified and resolved before the audit.

Your readiness team also extends beyond finance. CFO and CEO certifications cover the periodic report as a whole, not only the GAAP financial statements. Disclosure controls therefore must capture financial and nonfinancial information in time for disclosure decisions. Cybersecurity is a clear example. A domestic registrant must file a Form 8-K within four business days of determining that an incident is material, and must provide annual risk-management and governance disclosures in its Form 10-K. A disclosure committee with sign-offs from legal, finance, cyber, tax, and operations helps make sure nothing slips through.

The extended team can include specialists and technology as well. Business reporting has highlighted governance, data reliability, fraud, cybersecurity, and "black box" risks when generative AI is used in accounting and financial reporting. Similar concerns apply to valuation, actuarial, environmental, and other specialists whose work feeds material estimates. Keep an inventory of material models and specialist outputs, along with approved-use policies, source-data controls, human review, version history, and evidence of how each output was validated.

4. Stable internal controls are non-negotiable

Reliable internal controls are essential for companies of all sizes, particularly those experiencing rapid growth. Clear documentation of key financial processes and proper segregation of duties are vital. This is especially important for public companies, which need to show that they meet rigorous standards.

For public companies, this is a formal requirement. Management must maintain and annually assess ICFR and keep evidence that supports its conclusion. The SEC endorses a top-down, risk-based approach focused on the controls that address risks of material misstatement, including relevant entity-level, period-end, and IT controls. Some low-revenue and non-accelerated filers are exempt from auditor attestation under SOX 404(b), but they still must maintain ICFR and complete management's 404(a) assessment.

Companies in pre-revenue development phases, often with small finance teams, may struggle to balance workload and controls, but strong controls remain a priority. Testing matters as much as design. Past PCAOB inspection reports also found significant deficiencies in the testing of control design and operation.

When deficiencies surface, escalate and fix them before year-end. A material weakness prevents management from concluding that ICFR is effective. Significant deficiencies and material weaknesses must be communicated to the auditor and audit committee through the certification process. Severity depends on the possibility and size of a potential misstatement, not simply on whether a misstatement has already occurred. Auditors rely on these controls to assess financial integrity, so treat SOX and ICFR as a year-round evidence program. Regularly review and document procedures to confirm proper segregation and accountability.

5. Collaborate with your auditors to minimize surprises

The sooner you start working with your audit firm, the better. Clear communication with auditors from the beginning helps set expectations and align efforts, reducing last-minute surprises. Early collaboration also lets auditors offer perspectives that can both broaden your understanding of emerging trends and industry standards and make the process smoother and less disruptive.

That collaboration runs through the audit committee, which is formally responsible for appointing, paying, retaining, and overseeing the external auditor. Before issuing its report, the auditor must communicate its strategy, timing, significant risks, critical accounting policies and estimates, unusual transactions, misstatements, disagreements, and significant audit difficulties. The CFO's job is to give the committee balanced information early enough to challenge management and resolve issues.

Independence belongs in the relationship, too. Audit committees generally must pre-approve audit and permitted non-audit services before engagement. PCAOB Rule 3526 also requires written auditor communications about relationships that bear on independence, plus an annual written affirmation. Prohibited services, financial relationships, employment relationships, unpaid fees, and affiliate changes can all create independence issues. The 2026 inspection report flagged independence issues involving pre-approval, fees, financial relationships, and non-audit services.

Changing auditors deserves extra care. PCAOB data covering 2005 to 2024 show that "Big R" restatements occurred at roughly 3 percent annually. Of the companies with such restatements, 29 percent had changed auditors in the previous year, compared with an 11 percent average auditor-change rate across the broader population. The data show an association rather than causation. Even so, treat any auditor change as a high-risk transition that requires a complete transfer of prior-year issues, early alignment on accounting policy, independence clearance, and audit committee oversight.

Preparing for an audit requires careful planning and a proactive approach. The most audit-ready finance organizations can show three things at any point in the year. Their numbers and disclosures reconcile to controlled source information. Their significant judgments, controls, and remediation conclusions are backed by evidence recorded at the time. Their auditors and audit committee get complete, timely, and candid information. By addressing these five key areas (early preparation, record accuracy, team readiness, internal controls, and auditor collaboration), companies can turn the audit from a dreaded task into a process that adds value.

Meet the Author

Click a location marker
to learn more

GLOBAL SCALE. BOUTIQUE FEEL.

We are in the markets that matter, but we show up like we’re part of your team. Hands-on, high-touch, and built around your goals.